Corn Profitability Higher than Soybean Profitability in the Corn-belt: Will Corn Acres Increase?
The current supply and demand situation suggests a need for more corn acres in the upcoming 2011 production year. If corn acres are to increase, a sizable amount of the growth likely will come from the corn-belt. In the corn-belt, increases in corn acres cause reductions in soybean acres, as these two crops compete for acres. As farmers decide the proportion of corn and soybeans to plant, relative profitability of corn and soybeans likely enter into the decision-making process.
Projected 2011 Corn and Soybean Returns in Central Illinois
Currently, corn is projected to be more profitable than soybeans for the 2011 year. Corn and soybean returns were projected for high-productivity farmland in central Illinois. Commodity prices used in projections were $5.85 per bushel for corn and $13.25 per bushel for soybeans, near prices offered for fall delivery of grain in central Illinois. Yields used in projection were at trend-line for high-productivity farmland in central Illinois: 195 bushels for corn and 56 bushels for soybean. Non-land costs were taken from revised central Illinois budgets on farmdoc: $510 per acre for corn and $300 per acre for soybeans. The difference in non-land costs between corn and soybeans is $210 per acre. Corn returns were subtracted from soybean returns to arrive at corn-minus-soybean returns. Positive numbers indicate corn is projected to be more profitable than soybeans.
Projected 2011 corn-minus-soybean return on high-productivity farmland in central Illinois is projected at $189 per acre. This $189 value indicates that corn is projected to be $189 per acre more profitable than soybeans. The $189 value is high by historical standards. From 2004 through 2010, corn-minus-soybean returns averaged $48 per acre (see Figure 1). The highest corn-minus-soybean return of $118 per acre occurred in 2008, a year in which corn acres increased in Illinois.
Calculation of Breakeven Soybean-to-Corn Ratios
Corn being projected more profitable than soybeans is widespread over much of the corn-belt. Relative profitability of the two crops is examined with break-even soybean-to-corn ratios for each county in the corn-belt. Calculations begin with the following formula:
breakeven corn price = (cost difference + soybean price x soybean yield) / corn yield
where the breakeven corn price gives the price at which corn and soybeans have the same profits and the “cost difference” is the additional cost of producing corn rather than soybeans (see the Sept 17 Illinois Farm Economics: Facts and Opinions article titled “Breakeven Corn Prices for More Corn in 2007” for more detail). This equation serves as the basis for determining breakeven soybean-corn price ratios. The above equation is rearranged to calculate ratios for each county in the greater corn-belt using expected yields for each county.
In each county, historical corn and soybean yields from the National Agricultural Statistical Service, an agency of the U.S. Department of Agriculture are used to calculate trend-yields. For those counties where non-irrigated and irrigated data exists, non-irrigated yields are used. Counties that do not have sufficiently long yield series are not included in the analysis. Trend yields equal the linear trend through the 1972 through 2009 data extended to 2011.
The cost difference is set at $210 per acre, based on budgets for central Illinois. This indicates that corn production costs are $210 per acre higher than soybean production.
The above 2011 trend yields and cost difference are used to calculate breakeven soybean-to-corn ratios for each county. If soybean and corn prices result in a ratio less than the breakeven ratio, corn production is forecast to be more profitable than soybean production. If the price ratio is above the breakeven ratio, soybean production is more profitable than corn production. Take, for example a breakeven ratio of 2.8, a forecast corn price of $5.85 per bushel and a forecast soybean price of $13.25 per bushel. The forecast prices result in a ratio of 2.26 ($13.25 soybean price / $5.85 corn price). Corn production is more profitable than soybean production because the forecast price ratio of 2.26 is below the 2.8 breakeven ratios.
Breakeven Soybean-to-Corn Ratios
A map of break-even soybean-to-corn ratios is shown in Figure 2. When examining these ratios, two benchmarks are useful. Current cash bids place the soybean-to-corn ratio at 2.26 ($13.25 for soybean divided by $5.85 for corn). Counties with ratios less than 2.30, picked to be more conservative than the 2.26 current price ratio, are colored either red or orange. Counties in red have break-even soybean-to-corn price ratios below 2.00 while orange counties have ratios between 2.00 and 2.35. On average, farms in these counties will find soybeans more profitable than corn.
The second benchmark is 2.55. This is the average price ratio for January 2007 through December 2010 using monthly Illinois prices as reported by the US Department of Agriculture. In Figure 2, counties in red, orange, and yellow have breakeven ratios below 2.55. In yellow counties, soybeans would be more profitable than corn given historic soybean-to-corn price ratios, but this year’s current harvest-time bids suggest corn will be more profitable than soybeans in these counties.
Green counties in Figure 2 will have corn projected more profitable than soybeans given the historical ratio. Moreover, these counties likely will find corn more profitable than soybeans by a larger margin than usual as current price ratios favor corn production. As can be seen, most counties in southern Minnesota, Iowa, and Illinois are in green.
Over much of the corn-belt corn is projected more profitable than soybeans. Moreover, differences in corn returns are projected to be more than historically observed. Whether farmers will react to profit incentives remains to be seen. Overall there may be caution to switching to more corn because growing and harvest conditions in the past two years have been problematic in many areas of the corn-belt.
Returns presented in this paper are averages. Individual farms can vary significantly from these averages. Hence, farm specific budgets should be consulted when evaluating acreage decisions.
Disclaimer: We request all readers, electronic media and others follow our citation guidelines when re-posting articles from farmdoc daily. Guidelines are available here. The farmdoc daily website falls under University of Illinois copyright and intellectual property rights. For a detailed statement, please see the University of Illinois Copyright Information and Policies here.